Choosing the members of the management committee: the issues and the criteria for choosing

Mélanie

En charge des projets marketing chez WAYDEN, je suis passionnée par les sujets de management de transition, gestion de projets, marketing automation, community management, et de stratégie marketing.

Article mis à jour le 3 August 2026

The Executive Committee: definition, role and missions

The Executive Committee is the operational governance body that brings together, around the manager, the main functional and operational managers. Unlike the Executive Committee (which is often smaller and more strategic) or the Board of Directors (control body), the Management Committee steers the concrete implementation of the strategy.

It generally brings together the general manager or the CEO as well as the directors of different departments: CFO, sales director, marketing director, CIO, HR director, director of operations, etc. To better understand the distribution of roles between the main executive functions, the article COO, CFO and CEO: definitions, roles and missions details the respective responsibilities of each and their articulation within the general management.

The members of the Executive Committee have several key missions:

  • Define the company’s strategy : medium and long-term orientations, growth opportunities, reading of the competitive landscape, avenues for innovation.
  • Manage operational performance : monitoring of performance indicators, identification of corrective actions, decisions on priorities.
  • Oversee financial health : budget validation, profitability and cash flow monitoring, investment and financing decisions.
  • Ensure smooth communication between departments and with stakeholders.
  • Ensure cross-functional coordination between divisions and break down the logic of silos.
  • Leading the transformation : digitalization, restructuring, post-acquisition integration, ecological transition.

Meetings are usually held on a weekly or monthly basis, with an agenda structured around performance, current projects, obstacles encountered and opportunities to be seized.

Choosing a member of the Executive Committee: what are the challenges?

The selection of a member of the Executive Committee is of major importance, regardless of the size and sector of the company. Several structuring issues are linked to this decision: good governance, profitability, competitiveness, operational efficiency of field teams, commitment of middle managers, quality of strategic execution, financial health. The selection of the members of the management committee is therefore a determining factor for success and sustainability.

The recent economic context further reinforces the weight of this decision. The economic survey published in early 2025 by Bpifrance Le Lab highlights a marked wait-and-see climate among VSEs and SMEs, in an environment of political uncertainty and weakened demand. A well-composed executive committee then becomes a crucial lever for arbitrating quickly, securing cash flow and preserving margins.

Ideal composition of the Executive Committee: how many members and what profiles?

There is no universal model: the composition of a management committee depends on the size of the company, its sector, its maturity and its current challenges. However, a few common sense principles emerge.

The tightening rule

An effective executive committee remains sufficiently small to allow rapid decision-making. Beyond a dozen members, exchanges often become more formal, arbitrations are diluted and the collective dynamic runs out of steam. Successful committees are generally between five and nine people, with the possibility of inviting expert contributors from time to time depending on the topics covered.

Three main archetypes according to size

Industrial or service SMEs : a consolidated executive committee around the manager, the director of operations, the CFO, the sales director and the HR director is often enough to cover the main management levers. The marketing function and the IT department can be integrated as soon as digitalization becomes a strategic issue.

ETIs : the composition is enriched with a full-fledged marketing director, an R&D or innovation director, and frequently a supply chain director. Public programmes such as ETIncelles, led by the Directorate General for Enterprise, underline the extent to which the structuring of governance is a growth accelerator for this segment.

Large group : the management committee typically includes the general managers of subsidiaries or business units, the group CFO, the strategy director, the group HR director and the transformation director. Geographical and business diversity is becoming a criterion of composition in its own right.

Gender representation: a requirement that has become a regulatory requirement

The issue of gender diversity in management bodies is no longer just an image issue. The law of 24 December 2021 aimed at accelerating economic and professional equality has created an obligation of balanced representation between women and men among the senior executives and members of the management bodies of large companies. All companies that employ at least 1,000 employees for the third consecutive financial year must calculate and publish these representation gaps.

This dynamic is part of a broader public policy to accelerate professional equality and women’s economic autonomy. Each year, the Ministry for Gender Equality publishes a ranking of the feminization of the management bodies of SBF 120 companies, which serves as a reference for comparing practices. For growing mid-caps and SMEs, anticipating these requirements by integrating gender diversity from the construction of the Executive Committee avoids hasty restructurings when the regulatory threshold is crossed.

The criteria for selecting a member of the Executive Committee

The selection is generally made by the manager, sometimes in consultation with the board of directors or the reference shareholders. Four families of criteria structure the analysis.

Functional expertise and diversity of skills

Selecting members with a variety of know-how in finance, HR, marketing, operations, information systems is fundamental. This functional diversity makes it possible to approach the overall strategy from different angles and to produce informed decisions. In a mid-sized company, integrating a representative from each business unit (sales, marketing, HR, finance, production) remains a solid foundation. In a large group, the committee brings together the general managers of each subsidiary or region.

The complementarity of profiles and trajectories

Beyond the functional scope, the complementarity of the backgrounds makes the difference: profiles from consulting and pure operations, international backgrounds and local roots, sectoral expertise and external perspectives. This diversity is an effective antidote to one-size-fits-all thinking, which is particularly valuable in times of transformation or restructuring.

Adherence to corporate values and culture

The sharing of fundamental values, in line with the company’s culture, is a discriminating criterion. Identifying the human qualities of each person ensures that the decisions taken by the Executive Committee will remain consistent with the company’s philosophy. Values-based management is a useful framework for aligning governance and culture.

Leadership and human qualities

A member of the Executive Committee must have a strong sense of leadership: the ability to motivate, to unite teams, to manage stress in times of crisis, to make difficult decisions. Boldness, pragmatism, emotional intelligence, adaptability, resilience are among the essential qualities of a good manager. The ability to practice collective intelligence and to commit to a logic of operational excellence completes this foundation.

Things to doFavouring the complementarity of profiles, formalising a selection process, integrating gender diversity from the design of the Executive Committee, providing for occasional guests according to the subjects.
What to avoidStacking up functions for political reasons, multiplying members beyond ten, neglecting cultural alignment, forgetting to regularly evaluate the collective dynamic.

Examples of high-performance executive committee configurations

Growing industrial SMEs

An industrial SME benefits from relying on a tighter management committee: manager, director of operations, CFO, sales director, HR director. The IT department is invited as soon as industrial digitalization projects (MES, ERP, supervision) enter the active phase. This format allows for a short weekly rate and management of operational performance as close as possible to the field.

Mid-sized companies in digital transformation

A mid-sized company committed to a digital transformation expands its committee to include the CIO, a transformation director and a marketing director. The presence of an executive sponsor for AI and data topics is becoming a key factor: Wayden details in its article on the strategic uses of AI in business the skills to be mobilized to transform these topics into a competitive advantage.

Group in restructuring or post-acquisition

In a context of restructuring or post-acquisition integration, the Executive Committee frequently includes a program director, a legal director and a communications director. The use of an interim manager for a key function of the EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE – CFO, COO, HR – makes it possible to quickly stabilize governance while the permanent holder is recruited.

Selecting and keeping the Executive Committee alive: best practices

Before deciding on the composition of the Executive Committee, a rigorous selection process is required: definition of the scope of each role, in-depth individual interviews, collective situation, reference checks. The annual evaluation phase must then be extended to the dynamics of the committee as a whole: quality of decisions, speed of arbitration, level of transparency, ability to collectively lead the management of change.

The Executive Committee is not a fixed body. It evolves with the strategy: entry into growth, internationalization, technological shift, crisis. Re-examining its composition every 18 to 24 months is one of the good governance reflexes.

Strengthen your Executive Committee with an experienced

interim managerWayden assists managers, shareholders and funds in the recruitment of interim executive profiles to stabilize, transform or grow their management committees.

Talk to a Wayden expert

FAQ: member of the Executive Committee

What is the difference between the Executive Committee and the Executive Committee?

The COMEX (executive committee) is generally smaller and focused on high-level strategy. The Executive Committee has a more operational vocation, brings together more business directors and ensures the management of execution. In medium-sized structures, the two bodies are often confused.

How many members for an effective Executive Committee?

Practice recommends a narrow format, generally between five and nine members, to preserve the quality of exchanges and the speed of arbitration. Beyond that, the committee tends to lose collective dynamics.

Is gender diversity on the Executive Committee mandatory?

For companies employing at least 1,000 employees over three consecutive financial years, the law of 24 December 2021 requires the calculation and publication of the gender representation gap among senior executives and members of management bodies, with a progress trajectory to be respected.

Can an interim manager be integrated into the Executive Committee?

Yes, and it’s even frequent. An interim manager takes full responsibility for an executive position (CFO, COO, HRD, CIO) for a defined period of time: he sits on the Executive Committee in the same way as the other members and carries out the arbitrations related to his function.

How often should the Executive Committee meet?

The weekly or fortnightly rhythm is the most common for operational management, supplemented by quarterly or semi-annual strategic sessions dedicated to medium-term orientations.


© Wayden 2026 - All Rights Reserved - Legal